Brooks RussellBy Brooks Russell

Updated November 2026

Campfire cooking pie irons are the simplest way to turn bread, cheese and leftovers into hot, sealed sandwiches over coals. If you are shopping for one, the right choice depends on how many people you feed, how big your fire pit is and how much you want to fuss with cleanup. The six options below were compared on specifications, brand reputation and the patterns owners tend to report, with attention to handle design, plate size, weight and ease of cleaning. No product here was tested in the field, so treat the notes as a research summary rather than hands-on results.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Uno Casa Double Pie Iron XL | Cast Iron Campfire Sandwich Maker for CampingTOP CHOICEBest overallUno Casa Double Pie Iron XL | Cast Iron Campfire Sandwich Maker for CampingView on Amazon
  2. 2Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker, Campfire Sandwich Maker (Pack of 2)TOP CHOICEBest for familiesCast Iron Camp Pie Cooker, Campfire Sandwich Maker (Pack of 2)View on Amazon
  3. 3Coghlan's Cast Iron Camp Cooker - Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich MakerTOP CHOICEBest budget pickCoghlan's Cast Iron Camp Cooker – Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich MakerView on Amazon
  4. 4Cast Iron Sandwich Maker, Campfire Cooking Equipment, Pie Maker, Pie IronBest for small kitchens and RV tripsCast Iron Sandwich Maker, Campfire Cooking Equipment, Pie Maker, Pie IronView on Amazon
  5. 5Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, Cast Iron Campfire Pie CookerBest for mountain piesDouble Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, Cast Iron Campfire Pie CookerView on Amazon
  6. 6VEENEE 2 Pack Cast Iron Pie Iron, 5" Large Campfire Sandwich MakerBest for long-reach fire cookingVEENEE 2 Pack Cast Iron Pie Iron, 5" Large Campfire Sandwich MakerView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
Uno Casa Double Pie Iron XL | Cast Iron Campfire Sandwich Maker for Camping Making two sandwiches at once XL twin square heads with removable handles
Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker, Campfire Sandwich Maker (Pack of 2) Feeding a group in one sitting Two-pack for parallel cooking
Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker Beginners and occasional campers Pre-seasoned with heat-resistant removable handles
Cast Iron Sandwich Maker, Campfire Cooking Equipment Compact storage in small kitchens and RVs Multi-use for camping, outdoor and indoor baking
Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping Mountain pies and hearty fillings Double-sided design for fuller pies
VEENEE 2 Pack Cast Iron Pie Iron Reaching into a fire without getting too close Long handle and 5-inch plates

Uno Casa Double Pie Iron XL | Cast Iron Campfire Sandwich Maker for Camping

Two sandwiches per trip to the fire: XL twin square heads, removable handles and a recipe e-book in the box Uno Casa Double Pie Iron XL | Cast Iron Campfire Sandwich Maker for Camping

Two sandwiches per trip to the fire: XL twin square heads, removable handles and a recipe e-book in the box Uno Casa Double Pie Iron XL | Cast Iron Campfire Sandwich Maker for Camping

View on Amazon

Best for: Making two sandwiches per trip to the fire

This is a good fit for couples or small groups who want more output from each cooking session without managing multiple irons over the coals.

Key specs

  • Cast iron construction
  • XL twin square heads
  • Removable handles
  • Recipe e-book included in the box

Pros

  • Cooks two sandwiches at once
  • Removable handles make storage easier
  • Included recipe e-book adds ideas for new fillings

Cons

  • Larger footprint than single-sandwich irons
  • Heavier to pack than basic models

Bottom line: A strong all-around pick for campers who want two sandwiches per session and do not mind a little extra weight.

View on Amazon

Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker, Campfire Sandwich Maker (Pack of 2)

Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker, Campfire Sandwich Maker (Pack of 2)

Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker, Campfire Sandwich Maker (Pack of 2)

View on Amazon

Best for: Feeding a group in one sitting

Two irons let a family cook a round of sandwiches in parallel, which keeps the line moving when several people are hungry at once.

Key specs

  • Cast iron construction
  • Sold as a pack of two
  • Designed for campfire sandwiches

Pros

  • Two irons cook more food per round
  • Simple, classic design
  • Works with standard campfire coals

Cons

  • Cast iron needs seasoning and drying after use
  • Takes up more room in a camp box

Bottom line: Best suited to families or scout groups who want two irons on hand for larger crowds.

View on Amazon

Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker – Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich Maker

Coghlan's Cast Iron Camp Cooker - Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich Maker with Heat-Resistant, Removable Handles, Easy-to-Clean for Toasted Pies, Grilled Sandwiches, and Meats, For Campfire Cooking

Coghlan's Cast Iron Camp Cooker – Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich Maker with Heat-Resistant, Removable Handles, Easy-to-Clean for Toasted Pies, Grilled Sandwiches, and Meats, For Campfire Cooking

View on Amazon

Best for: Beginners and occasional campers

The pre-seasoned surface and heat-resistant removable handles make this a low-fuss starting point for people new to pie irons.

Key specs

  • Cast iron, pre-seasoned
  • Heat-resistant removable handles
  • Suitable for pies, grilled sandwiches and meats

Pros

  • Pre-seasoned for less prep before the first use
  • Removable handles help with storage and handling
  • Versatile beyond basic sandwiches

Cons

  • Single-iron design cooks one pie at a time
  • Still needs drying and light oiling to prevent rust

Bottom line: A sensible choice for first-time buyers who want a straightforward iron that handles more than sandwiches.

View on Amazon

Cast Iron Sandwich Maker, Campfire Cooking Equipment, Pie Maker, Pie Iron

Cast Iron Sandwich Maker, Campfire Cooking Equipment, Pie Maker, Pie Iron Suitable for Outdoor/Camping/Kitchen/Baking Sandwiches

Cast Iron Sandwich Maker, Campfire Cooking Equipment, Pie Maker, Pie Iron Suitable for Outdoor/Camping/Kitchen/Baking Sandwiches

View on Amazon

Best for: Compact storage in small kitchens and RVs

Listed for camping, outdoor cooking and home kitchen use, so it can double as a sandwich maker when you are not at a campsite.

Key specs

  • Cast iron construction
  • Suitable for outdoor, camping and kitchen use
  • Designed for sandwiches and baked pies

Pros

  • Works indoors and outdoors
  • Compact profile for tight storage
  • Good match for RV and van trips

Cons

  • Plate size is smaller than XL-style models
  • Cast iron requires regular seasoning care

Bottom line: Ideal for campers with limited storage or those who want one iron that also works in a home kitchen.

View on Amazon

Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, Cast Iron Campfire Pie Cooker

Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, Cast Iron Campfire Pie Cooker, Campfire Cooking Equipment Mountain Pie Maker

Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, Cast Iron Campfire Pie Cooker, Campfire Cooking Equipment Mountain Pie Maker

View on Amazon

Best for: Mountain pies and hearty fillings

The double-sided design gives fuller coverage, which suits thicker fillings like leftover chili or stew.

Key specs

  • Cast iron construction
  • Double-sided pie iron design
  • Marketed for mountain pies and campfire cooking

Pros

  • Sealed edges hold heartier fillings
  • Good for leftovers and bulkier recipes
  • Simple to use over a bed of coals

Cons

  • Heavier than single-sided options
  • Thicker pies take longer to heat through

Bottom line: A good pick for campers who plan to make filling-heavy pies and want even coverage on both sides.

View on Amazon

VEENEE 2 Pack Cast Iron Pie Iron, 5″ Large Campfire Sandwich Maker

Heavy Duty Outdoor Camping Cooker with Long Handle for Mountain Pies, Pudgie Pies & Grilled Sandwiches, RV Trips & Bonfires VEENEE 2 Pack Cast Iron Pie Iron, 5" Large Campfire Sandwich Maker

Heavy Duty Outdoor Camping Cooker with Long Handle for Mountain Pies, Pudgie Pies & Grilled Sandwiches, RV Trips & Bonfires VEENEE 2 Pack Cast Iron Pie Iron, 5" Large Campfire Sandwich Maker

View on Amazon

Best for: Reaching into a fire without getting too close

The long handle and 5-inch plates put more distance between your hands and the heat, which many campers appreciate around a roaring fire.

Key specs

  • Cast iron, two-pack
  • 5-inch large plates
  • Long handle for fire cooking

Pros

  • Long handle keeps hands further from flames
  • Two irons for group cooking
  • Large plates fit bigger sandwiches

Cons

  • Long handles take more storage space
  • Cast iron requires drying to prevent rust

Bottom line: Best for campers who cook over larger fire pits and want extra reach and plate size.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Plate Size and Sandwich Count

Standard pie irons usually have plates in the 4- to 5-inch range. Larger plates hold bigger sandwiches but heat more slowly. If you cook for four or more, consider a two-pack or double-head design so you are not waiting on one iron at a time.

Good picks for this: Uno Casa Double Pie Iron XL, Cast Iron Camp Pie Cooker (Pack of 2)

Handle Length and Reach

Handles should keep your hands well clear of the flames. Long handles, roughly 18 inches or more, help when cooking over a wide fire pit. Removable handles save space in a pack but check that they lock securely before you close the iron.

Good picks for this: VEENEE 2 Pack Cast Iron Pie Iron, Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker

Weight and Packability

Cast iron is heavy. If you backpack, a single iron with removable handles is easier to carry than a pair. For car camping, weight matters less, so you can choose larger, sturdier models.

Good picks for this: Cast Iron Sandwich Maker, Campfire Cooking Equipment, Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker

Seal Quality and Edge Design

A good pie iron closes tightly so the filling stays inside. Look for flat, well-machined edges and a hinge that does not wobble. Sealed edges matter most for wet fillings like eggs or sauce.

Good picks for this: Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, Uno Casa Double Pie Iron XL

Cast Iron Care and Seasoning

Most pie irons are cast iron and need to be dried over heat and wiped with a thin layer of cooking oil after each use. Pre-seasoned models reduce early prep, but all cast iron can rust if left wet. Store it dry, and avoid soaking it.

Good picks for this: Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker, Cast Iron Sandwich Maker, Campfire Cooking Equipment

Versatility Beyond Sandwiches

If you want to make pies, grilled meats or baked snacks, check for a deep-enough cavity and a sturdy build. Single-purpose irons are fine for sandwiches only, but multi-use models offer more meal options from one tool.

Good picks for this: Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker, Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping

Storage and Fit in Your Camp Kit

Measure your camp box or tote before buying. Two irons with long handles can fill a standard bin quickly. Removable handles and compact profiles make it easier to stack gear alongside pots, utensils and fuel.

Good picks for this: Cast Iron Sandwich Maker, Campfire Cooking Equipment, Uno Casa Double Pie Iron XL

FAQ

What is the best size pie iron for camping?

For most couples or small families, a standard 4- to 5-inch plate works well. Larger plates hold bigger sandwiches but take longer to heat through, so match the size to how many people you usually feed.

Do I need to season a cast iron pie iron before using it?

Some models are pre-seasoned, while others need a thin coat of oil and a short heating session before the first use. Check the manufacturer’s care instructions for the specific model you buy.

How do I keep a pie iron from sticking?

Lightly oil the plates before each use, and make sure the iron is hot but not smoking. Bread that is slightly stale and fillings that are not too wet also reduce sticking.

Can I use a pie iron on a gas grill or stove?

Many cast iron pie irons can be used on a stove or grill, but confirm with the manufacturer first. Avoid placing any iron directly in an open flame for long periods, as handles and hinges can overheat.

How do I clean a pie iron after cooking?

Let the iron cool slightly, then scrape out food residue with a wooden or silicone tool. Rinse lightly with hot water if needed, dry it completely over low heat, and wipe with a thin coat of oil before storing.

Is a double pie iron better than a single one?

A double iron cooks two sandwiches at once, which saves time for groups. A single iron is lighter and easier to store, so it suits solo campers or those with limited pack space.

What fillings work best in a pie iron?

Cheese, cooked meats, leftover vegetables and canned fillings all work well. Keep wet ingredients to a minimum so the edges seal properly, and avoid overfilling, which can cause leaks.

Conclusion

For most campers, the Uno Casa Double Pie Iron XL offers the best balance of output and convenience. Families and groups will get the most out of the two-pack options, while beginners may prefer the pre-seasoned Coghlan’s model. Backpackers and RV owners should look at the compact Cast Iron Sandwich Maker, and campers cooking over large fire pits will appreciate the long handles on the VEENEE two-pack. Match your choice to your group size, storage space and cooking style, and you will have a reliable tool for campfire sandwiches for seasons to come.

Sources

Brooks Russell

About Brooks Russell

Brooks focuses on practical advice for camping know-how: what matters before you buy, what to skip, and how to get more out of what you already own.